Learning Something New, One Brew at a Time

Learning Something New, One Brew at a Time

When I was working before retiring in October 2025, I lived by the motto “Learn something new every day.” In my job, I had to. The environment was constantly changing, and staying on top of things meant continuing to learn, adapt and adjust.

Turns out, retirement hasn’t changed that much.

Especially when it comes to home brewing.

Time for a Second Opinion

I recently brought another bottle of my Paso Pioneer Ale to the brewers at Cal Coast Beer Co., where I’ve been working since June. One of the perks of the job, at least for a home brewer like me, is having access to people who know a hell of a lot more about brewing beer than I do.

This was the first bottle of Paso Pioneer Ale I’ve brought in for their opinion. I wanted to know what they thought was right, what was wrong and, most importantly, where I might need to make adjustments.

At this point, I had opened two bottles myself.

The beer was originally supposed to be a West Coast IPA, but it ended up drinking more like a softer West Coast pale ale. I’ve already written about that here on Contributing Factor Brewing.

But there was another issue I was concerned about.

Was It Really an Off-Flavor?

When I first tasted the beer, I thought I detected something medicinal — almost like a Band-Aid — or perhaps an overly herbal bite.

After my first couple of bottles, I started wondering if I had somehow created a chlorophenol problem with the water I added at the end of brew day.

So I brought a bottle to the experts.

And the answer surprised me.

They didn’t taste an off-flavor.

That doesn’t mean I suddenly love the beer. I still don’t think this is a particularly good beer. But there’s a difference between a beer having a true off-flavor and a beer simply having a flavor profile that isn’t working for me.

That’s an important distinction.

There Were Plenty of Positives

The interesting part is that there is actually quite a bit to like about this batch.

The head was strong, and the head retention was good. The beer left nice lacing on the glass. The color was right where I wanted it, and the clarity turned out well.

Visually, this beer checks a lot of boxes.

But as I’ve learned, a great-looking beer doesn’t mean much if you don’t enjoy drinking it.

And I still don’t.

The brewers’ assessment, however, changed my thinking about why.

I May Have Overdone the Water Chemistry

After tasting the beer and talking through the brewing process, the consensus was that I may have over-treated my brewing water.

The likely suspects?

Calcium chloride.
Gypsum.
Possibly even lactic acid.

In other words, I may have been trying too hard to make the water perfect and ended up pushing the mineral profile too far in the wrong direction.

That would explain something I’ve been noticing as I’ve started digging deeper into brewing water chemistry. The water is technically there to support the beer, but the mineral additions can have a significant impact on the finished flavor.

And I’ve been playing with those calculations.

A lot.

I’ve spent hours working through water profiles and salt additions on Brewer’s Friend, comparing different recommendations and even consulting AI. And, of course, every time I run the numbers, I seem to get an answer that’s just a little different.

Which brings me back to that motto:

Learn something new every day.

Apparently, I have a lot more to learn about brewing water.

What’s Next?

So where do I go from here?

Back to the basics.

I need to get a better handle on properly treating RO water without throwing too much of anything into it. I need to understand what each addition is actually doing to the beer rather than simply chasing numbers in a calculator.

And I still have plenty of new equipment to learn.

I’ve got the BrewZilla sitting there waiting for its next brew day. I’ve got the new kegerator, which still needs a few parts before I can get it completely dialed in. And then there’s learning how to use it beyond simply pouring beer.

I’m also looking into whether I can use the kegerator for things like cold crashing and temperature control.

So, apparently, retirement hasn’t eliminated the need to learn something new every day.

It just changed what I’m learning.

And honestly?

I’m having a hell of a lot of fun doing it.

Contributing Factor Brewing
Brew. Learn. Share.